The materials currently organized in the records include programs and event schedules from the annual meetings, printed copies of papers presented at these meetings, correspondence, membership rolls, news clippings, and various journals. When the collection was organized in August of 1996, these items were largely arranged chronologically, with each year given its own file folder. New folders are added as future materials are donated by the Academy.

The Lois Anne Montelius Dodge Manuscript Collection contains course notes, papers, pamphlets, syllabi and works by others on a wide range of Christian topics and subjects related to her academic work at Princeton Theological Seminary.

The William Howard Dodge Manuscript Collection contains course notes, papers, pamphlets, syllabi and works by others on a wide range of Christian topics and subjects related to his academic work at Princeton Theological Seminary.